Suspect Scott #667 Unused Single.
This is a suspect #667 "Kans." overprint used single that I found in an auction
lot that I bought some time ago. I've been trying to formulate a
systematic procedure for determining if a suspect overprinted stamp is genuine
or not. I've determined that there are four areas to look at that at a
minimum will determine if a suspect overprinted stamp is genuine or not whether
it's used or unused. A problem with any of the following five steps would
be grounds to say that a suspect overprinted stamp is a fake.
- Check the perforations: Genuine overprints were only applied to the perf 11X10
1/2 issues. You'd be surprised how many fakes I've seen on perf 11X11 or
10X10 stamps.
- Check the gum breakers: Without exception all genuine unused Nebr./Kans.
overprints have gum breakers that are spaced 22mm (Type II) apart which means
that there will only be one gum breaker on the back unless the breakers are at
the very top and very bottom perforations of the stamp. Any suspect overprint
stamp found with more than one gum breaker can be considered a fake.
- Check the suspect overprint against a known genuine overprint. The best
way of doing this test is to use imaging software to overlay a slightly
transparent image of the suspect overprint on top of the known genuine
overprint. with this method the size, spacing and shape of the suspect
overprint can be compared directly to the known good overprint.
- Check the back to see if the overprint comes through: Genuine overprints were
applied using a surface printing method of electrotype which only leaves ink on
the surface of the stamp. a fake done with a typewriter would depress the
surface which would leave corresponding bumps on the back of the stamp.
- Check the color of the suspect against the color of a known genuine overprinted
stamp: This would be a method of last resort since the color of the suspect may
have been altered due to natural causes or the colors of the genuine stamps may
not be exact. In most cases a fake will be found long before the need to
check the color.
What is the perforation gauge of the two sides?
- The suspect gauges out to the correct 11 X 10 1/2.
If used are any gum breakers present?
- Even though the gum is slightly glazed there are signs of a single gum breaker
near the top of the stamp as well as the vertical striations in the gum. Another
thing to notice is that the overprint shows through to the back of the stamp as
well as there are bumps where the overprint has punched through the paper – both
cases are impossible with genuine overprints.
Compare the suspect overprint with a known genuine overprint.
- The overprint in no way matches a known genuine overprint – it is narrower and the font is wrong.
Conclusion: In my opinion the suspect is a Scott #641 with a fake overprint applied – most likely with a typewriter.
As always comments and suggestions are always welcome.
To Contact Riverside
To Contact Riverside Stamps:
Email:
Mike Girard - Owner / Operator / Web Master:
g1rardmn1099@comcast.net
I am a member of the American Philatelic Society
APS #: 205494
Visit the American Philatelic Society Website at www.stamps.org |
I am a member of the United States Stamp Society
USSS #: 16733
Visit the United States Stamp Society Website at
www.usstamps.org |
I am a member of the Perfins Club
Perfins Club #: 4266
Visit The Perfins Club Website at
https://www.perfins.org/
|
|